The peel. Acommonly overlooked piece of the puzzle when it comes to making pizza. Dough recipes, sauce recipes, expensive cheeses, hot ovens, steels - all important in making delicious pizzas - become a waste of money and time when you don’t have the proper tool for getting that soon to be incredible pizza into the oven.
__________________________________________________________________________
Wooden peels:
Wooden peels, used by pizzerias across the world, are wonderful for launching pizza. They are naturally the least sticky of any peel given their relative coarse surface compared to metal peels. With a slight dusting of flour they become the perfect vehicle for launching. Wooden peels have some weight to them, but that weight also allows them to be able to handle larger and heavier pizzas loaded with toppings.
With anything, there are some drawbacks. A wooden peel benefits greatly from a dusting of flour, but using too much means raw flour can cake onto the bottom of the pizza.
You’re also unable to easily slide a pizza from the counter to peel as wooden peels are too thick - toppings would roll off as the pizza is slid on. Therefore building the pizza on the peel works well, but if you aren’t experienced with topping, i.e. fast enough, the dough can stick to the peel, ensuring a disaster.
Lastly, you can’t easily remove a pizza with a wooden peel. It’s thickness becomes a major disadvantage when trying to slide it under the cooked pizza and steel.
__________________________________________________________________________
Metal peels:
Metal peels, while popular and maybe the first peel a home pizza maker purchases, are actually HORRIBLE for launching pizzas. Due to their very shiny and surface, pizza dough practically suction cups to them.
Of course everyone knows to use some flour to assist with launching, but the amount of flour needed for a metal peel to successfully launch a pizza is to the point where it negatively affects the pizza’s bottom, almost always with caked on raw flour.
So toss the metal peel in the trash? Absolutely not! How are you going to get the pizza out of your oven? A thin, lightweight, metal peel is the perfect tool for removing a pizza from the oven.
__________________________________________________________________________
Perforated metal peels:
Somewhat new to the world of pizza, perforated metal peels (metal peels with slots cut into them) are very popular with Neapolitan pizzas. Very light and thin, they can be slid right underneath a pizza to load it or the pizza can easily be dragged onto it.
The perforations in the peel mean less metal is touching the actual bottom of the pizza and they allow excess flour to shake off in the process of taking it from peel to oven.
They don’t do well with larger, heavier pizzas and pizzas shouldn’t be topped on them as the longer a pizza sits on it the higher chance it has of sticking and sinking into the perforations.
If baking pizzas in the 10”-13” diameter range, a perforated metal peel may be the best of what wooden peels have to offer in terms of launching while having the ability to remove pizzas as well. Light, thin, and shiny - what’s not to like?